[George C. Daughan] ô If By Sea: The Forging of the American Navy -From the Revolution to the War of 1812 [literary-fiction PDF] Ebook Epub Download ☆ pamyatnik.pro
[George C. Daughan] ô If By Sea: The Forging of the American Navy -From the Revolution to the War of 1812 [literary-fiction PDF] Ebook Epub Download ☆ Ugh is all I can say I ve been reading a lot on the War of 1812 and early American Navy history and this is the worst one I ve read The author is obsessed with the concept that it was wrong for the Continental Navy to build warships instead of Row galleys and whaleboats Seriously, he mentions them about once a paragraph Every time the navy is defeated, it is if only the navy had built row galleys and whaleboats Um, just guessing that a few dozen rowboats with 1 cannon would not have scared the Royal Navy The fault lies with the leadership of the Continental Navy Also, he overgeneralizes waaaaaaay too much Sigh.
George Daughan s If By Sea The Forging of the American Navy from the Revolution to the War of 1812 tells a well researched version of the early history of the US Navy In at times tedious but exemplary detail he traces the Navy from it s initial successes failures during the Revolutionary War across the first 4 presidential administrations the objections to the Navy s existence The historical detail is very well done as we the reader get a chance to see some of the lesser known feats of this fledgling fleet of ships witness the travails as it even tries to succeed in existence It helps the fact that interspersed with this are the various crises in the Washington, Adams, Jefferson Madison administrations that warrant not only the existence of such a branch of the military but the necessity of it Overall a very well done early history of what is still at times one of the mo The American Revolution And Thus The History Of The United States Began Not On Land But On The Sea Paul Revere Began His Famous Midnight Ride Not By Jumping On A Horse, But By Scrambling Into A Skiff With Two Other Brave Patriots To Cross Boston Harbor To Charlestown Revere And His Companions Rowed With Muffled Oars To Avoid Capture By The British Warships Closely Guarding The Harbor As They Paddled Silently, Revere S Neighbor Was Flashing Two Lanterns From The Belfry Of Old North Church, Signaling Patriots In Charlestown That The Redcoats Were Crossing The Charles River In Longboats In Every Major Revolutionary Battle Thereafter The Sea Would Play A Vital, If Historically Neglected, Role When The American Colonies Took Up Arms Against Great Britain, They Were Confronting The Greatest Sea Power Of The Age And It Was During The War Of Independence That The American Navy Was Born But Following The British Naval Model Proved Crushingly Expensive, And The Founding Fathers Fought Viciously For Decades Over Whether Or Not The Fledgling Republic Truly Needed A Deep Water Fleet The Debate Ended Only When The Federal Navy Proved Indispensable During The War Of Drawing On Decades Of Prodigious Research, Historian George C Daughan Chronicles The Embattled Origins Of The US Navy From The Bloody And Gunpowder Drenched Battles Fought By American Sailors On Lakes And High Seas To The Fierce Rhetorical Combat Waged By The Founders In Congress, If By Sea Charts The Course By Which The Navy Became A Vital And Celebrated American Institution Basically, the American Navy could have been effective if they had the same hindsight that Daughan writes with.
Daughan spent a lot of time describing the land battles of the Revolutionary War Interesting, for sure, but I already knew a lot of these details, and I would have preferred he spent those pages describing the navy in detail or just remove them entirely Why do historians feel the need to write such thick books when a shorter book would cover the material just as well.
It s a pity that Jefferson s poor decision making extended to the creation of the Navy In fact, Jefferson s poor judgment informed by his blind idealism is a recurring theme in just about every history book I ve read in which he is a participant Also, every time I read an account of the American Revolution, it becomes increasingly clear how ridiculously improbable it was for the Ame Thoroughly enjoyed this book An amazing and well written study on the overall picture of American military foundations and how the Navy is part of the country s earliest beginnings Highly recommend A good book with a lot of interesting facts and information It is well written and easy to read However, it is somewhat marred by a lot of repetitive complaints about what might have been done if people had better looked at what they were doing and too much detail about maneuvers of the land based army that wasn t completely relevant to the narrative.
This book provides a good survey of this period of American History in addition to covering the origins of the US Navy I did note other reviewers complaints about the author s repeated assertions about whale boats and gunboats with little analysis of how likely they were to be successful and how quickly the Royal Navy would respond to this type of warfare I think the RN would have adapted to this threat and that it wouldn t have been the war winner that the author contends although maybe it could have lead to an earlier settlement of the conflict we ll never be able to say so for sure I enjoyed this as a nice general overview of the period, but I would need to do additional reading to fully agree with the author s hostility towards Thomas Jefferson One thing that I do know about this period is that the incompetence, selfishness, missed opportunities and eve
This book was a great read I have been studying the Royal Navy and the early Continental Navy for the past six months and this provided some good insight into the early formation of the Continental Navy as well as identifying the constant struggle between the Washington Adams view of Armed Neutrality during and post American Revolution and the Jefferson Madison view of exhaustive diplomacy pre and during the War of 1812 In the end, Madison did see that Armed Neutrality was the best course to take.
I want the reader to understand that this book does emphasize that it is a focus on the early American Navy formation, but it is not entriely about that The author does take some time to address land battles, but these battles did lead to navy involvement or could have led to American victory s much quicker if the Navy was developed speedily and without suc Finished, a good 3 1 2 Stars but probably not one to make my permanent collection He does a good job of covering the fledgling Continental Navy, from the pork barrel effort to build the first batch of frigates to their eventual demise at the hands of the Royal Navy His contention is the US Navy was born in the Revolutionary War rather than in the 1790 s, as is commonly agreed He covers many naval actions, large and small to make the point As many other reviewers have noted, he beats a dead horse on the failure of the Continentals to build hundreds of Whaleboats and row galleys to use in guerrilla raids against the British Navy He believes that would have been far effective rather than trying to mirror the ships and tactics of the greatest naval power in the world, as the Continentals do He brings some fair criticism to the conduct of naval operations and what the combatants could