Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓

[Epub] ➚ Battle for the Rhine 1944 By Robin Neillands – Pamyatnik.pro Who was really responsible for the failure at Nijmegen the destruction of the British First Airborne Division at Arnhem and the failure of Operation Market Garden? Why was Montgomery threatened with tWho was really responsible for the failure at Nijmegen the destruction of the British First Airborne Division at Arnhem and the failure of Operation Market Garden? Why was Montgomery threatened with the sack when he had just retrieved Bradley's failure in the Battle of the Bulge? Was General Eisenhower's command strategy either workable or wise and did.

Bradley and Patton undermine it? Even after sixty years the uestions remain In this account of the 1944 post Normandy campaign historian Robin Neillands disentangles events from the media myths that have come to surround them to get to the truth of what really happened He examines the often difficult relationship between General Eisenhower and British F.

battle pdf rhine epub 1944 download Battle for pdf the Rhine mobile for the Rhine ebok Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBBradley and Patton undermine it? Even after sixty years the uestions remain In this account of the 1944 post Normandy campaign historian Robin Neillands disentangles events from the media myths that have come to surround them to get to the truth of what really happened He examines the often difficult relationship between General Eisenhower and British F.

Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine  eBook ✓

Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ Robin Hunter Neillands was a British writer who specialized in travel and military history He also wrote under several pen names Robin Hunter Rob Hunter Neil Lands and Debbie Hunter Neillands served in 45 Commando Royal Marines in Cyprus and the Middle East Afterwards as a salesman for Pan Books he travelled widely In Britain he founded Spur Books and through them published his early tr

10 thoughts on “Battle for the Rhine 1944

  1. Dj Dj says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBThis book points out some of the best and worst things that can come about from studying history The author seems to have come into this project with a goal and thus is at times focused on this agenda than on presenting the facts His Agenda is a simple one and one that doesn't lack in merit He wants to redeem Field Marshall Montgomery and show that he was the only viable and the correct choice to be the Ground Force Commander in the ETO He seems to have a number of basic arguments why this should be the case And two against it They are basically as follows 1The Positions of Supreme Commander and Ground Forces Commander was too much for one person2Montgomery was the only one with the Experience to take the ro


  2. Dimitri Dimitri says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBBattle for the Rhine?Battle between the GeneralsNow without that nasty David Irving flavour


  3. Dwain Dwain says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBThis book should have been called Monty's Battle to Overcome the Stupidity of the American Generals and Beat the Nazis single handed That would have accurately indicated the tone of the book While I appreciate that the author had a thesis and that he backs up his claims with uite a bit of evidence the tone was overbearing and ex


  4. Lee Lee says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBA good look at the strategy of this period of the war He claims to bridge the Monty vs Patton argument that historians amateur and otherwise break down but he's clearly on Montgomery's side He does a very good job of backing it up though He's not very complimentary to most American generals and perhaps rightly so but I think he is excessively harsh on Patton That said I'm emotionally a Patton o phile but I am convinced that Montgomery had some right ideas


  5. Tom Schulte Tom Schulte says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBThis is a deeply detailed and exhaustively research account from the first hours after D Day up to The Battle of the Bulge Sometimes repetetive as a Montogmery apologist this author also takes Patton down a few notches This account makes for good balanced reading to the dramatic and simplified popular accounts of the movies Patton and A Bridge too Far


  6. Jemma Jemma says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBAn enlightening account of what happened between the breakout from Normandy in August '44 and January '45 Not really a book to bother with though unless you are interested in such details as why did it take the Allies so long to make the Rhine when things were going so well? Of course parts of the answer are Arnhem and the Bulge but they are not the whole story as they are two months apart A fuller picture includes a lack of a clear strategy; people not following the strategy such as it was; personality clashes; an American supply corps which was a law unto itself; Eisenhower trying to do two highly demanding jobs which took him in d


  7. Steven A Lemmel Steven A Lemmel says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBA well written well researched historical analysis of the time period He argues logically that General Eisenhower's strategy from September through December 1944 was ineffective and may have prolonged the war several months He hails Eisenhower as a great Supreme commander but an indifferent ground forces commander In the author's opinion Ike failed to adeuately grip his immediate subordinates especially George Pa


  8. Brian Hogg Brian Hogg says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBThe real truthA fair review of the truthObviously Monty was held back but he was the most level headed Commander not searching for personal glory but by good reasoning knowing the enemies possible movesAbove all doing his best to not waste mens livesBrilliant well researched book


  9. Jason Jason says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBLess of a history and of a misplaced dispute on how history has regarded personalities of the war and who was responsible for winning Generals Ike Bradley Patton and MacArthur are consistently torn down and the praise for Monty gets repetitively nauseous


  10. Jamie Burrell Jamie Burrell says:

    Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ battle pdf, rhine epub, 1944 download, Battle for pdf, the Rhine mobile, for the Rhine ebok, Battle for the Rhine 1944 ePUBGives an alternative viewDefinitely an eye opener to an alternative view However by its nature the subject was a little dry and occasionally the


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Robin Neillands

Epub Robin Neillands ✓ Battle for the Rhine 1944 PDF À the Rhine eBook ✓ Robin Hunter Neillands was a British writer who specialized in travel and military history He also wrote under several pen names Robin Hunter Rob Hunter Neil Lands and Debbie Hunter Neillands served in 45 Commando Royal Marines in Cyprus and the Middle East Afterwards as a salesman for Pan Books he travelled widely In Britain he founded Spur Books and through them published his early tr