[Adam Nicolson] é Seize the Fire: Heroism, Duty, and Nelson's Battle of Trafalgar (P.S.) [17th-century PDF] Ebook Epub Download Ý pamyatnik.pro
[Adam Nicolson] é Seize the Fire: Heroism, Duty, and Nelson's Battle of Trafalgar (P.S.) [17th-century PDF] Ebook Epub Download Ý In Seize The Fire, Adam Nicolson, Author Of The Widely Acclaimed God S Secretaries, Takes The Great Naval Battle Of Trafalgar, Fought Between The British And Franco Spanish Fleets In October , And Uses It To Examine Our Idea Of Heroism And The Heroic Is Violence A Necessary Aspect Of The Hero And Daring Why Did The Cult Of The Hero Flower In The Late Eighteenth And Nineteenth Centuries In A Way It Hadn T For Two Hundred Years Was The Figure Of Nelson Intemperate, Charming, Theatrical, Anxious, Impetuous, Considerate, Indifferent To Death And Danger, Inspirational To Those Around Him, And, Above All, Fixed On Attack And Victory An Aberration In Enlightenment England Or Was The Greatest Of All English Military Heroes Simply The Product Of His Time, The Conjurer Of Violence That England, At Some Level, Deeply Needed It Is A Story Rich With Modern Resonance This Was A Battle Fought For The Control Of A Global Commercial Empire It Was Won By The Emerging British World Power, Which Was Widely Condemned On The Continent Of Europe As The Arrogant Usurper Of The Freedom Of The Seas Seize The Fire Not Only Vividly Describes The Brutal Realities Of Battle But Enters The Hearts And Minds Of The Men Who Were There It Is A Portrait Of A Moment, A Close And Passionately Engaged Depiction Of A Frame Of Mind At A Turning Point In World History This is an excellent account on arguably the most pivotal naval battle in modern history The author openly admits to not being a naval scholar yet his book reads very well and the descriptions of naval combat in the age of sail are simply beach taking as is the detail and depth of every page of this fine work.
This is a highly recommend account on Trafalgar Forgive my political incorrectness but in the words of Billy Connelly it s f ing brilliant Far from just a recounting of the battle though there is plenty of that, in intense detail , this is also a study in the kinds of societies the commercial British, the almost medieval and aristocratic Spanish, and the weirdly old fashioned yet supposedly revolutionary French that produced the ships, officers and seamen who fought in it Nelson s death gets a tight focus, but there s also some art and literary criticism of the works inspired by Trafalgar and a sociological take on the turn of the 19th century that I haven t really encountered before Good stuff.
Today is the 200th Anniversary of Trafalgar and Nelson s death The battle was fought in the Atlantic off Cape Trafalgar near the harbor and port of Cadiz, Spain Coincidently but very appropriately, I finished Adam Nicolson s excellent Seize the Fire today.
Napoleon, by 1805, controlled all Europe west of Austria including northern Italy and Spain through arms and diplomacy England, as it would again 145 years later, stood alone France s fleet was potentially capable of invading Britain but only if it could defeat the Royal Navy.
Two years earlier, Nelson chased the French fleet from the Caribbean to Cadiz without engaging in battle During the next two years 15% of the British fleet under Nelson blockaded Cadiz daring the combined French and Spanish fleet to come out to fight Finally, the Combined Fleet leadership decided to fight According to Nicolson the British were co This was an ambitious book The emphasis isn t so much an account of the battle of Trafalgar though the battle is covered but how the new concept of duty and honor carried the day for the English I ve always thought it an error of omission that the larger books on the Napoleonic Wars often entirely skip over the naval arena, with just brief mentions of the Battle of the Nile and Trafalgar or the blockades After reading this book, I consider it even worse now that attention isn t paid Occasionally, the author overreaches a bit with his thesis, and I could have done without Ruskin and Wordsworth bits at the end, since I don t think either is relevant to the point he is trying to make I wasn t expecting to find a book like this to be so incredibly moving and touching and it s packed with aw inducing letters and Moderate coverage of the battle and aftermath Most of the book is taken with examining the national characteristics of the English, French and Spanish He goes on about why the winners won and the losers lost, and that s where it usually gets pedantic One of the author s points is that the English were moving into a phase of a violence prone and capitalistic national character, seeming to imply that to be capitalistic is to be violence prone, and that s why Nelson designed his attack for maximum violence However, one could say that about most battle winners, capitalist or socialist Isn t that what a wartime battle attempts to do exact maximum damage or loss to the enemy In fact, had Nelson lost, blame for his battle plan would have fallen on his head like tons of cannon balls This is simply a magnificent book for those interested in the battle of Trafalgar This book focused on the lives of those on the ships, the methods of fighting at sea and how they differed between the British, French and Spanish, and the sea of blood that was the day of the battle This is one of the most well written books I have read on the subject to date It is a fine mix of very technical and historical text as well as great storytelling which stops this from being a dry historical book and turns it into a story that can be read by hard core fans of the battle and those who are interested in learning about the subject.
More than a book about the battle, Nicolson the author of the splendid God s Secretaries has produced a meta history of the 21st of October, 1805 And most of the book helps the reader imagine the minds of the officers, men, and land lubbers on that day So if you want the social connotation of naval warfare, this is the best I ve read.
Other books contain technical detail about the battle this one is about Nelson and Trafalgar s time, and place in history If you re looking for military history, look elsewhere.
Nicolson argues that Trafalgar was the triangular divergence of three conceptions of statehood 1 Authoritarian and traditionalist Spain hopelessly incapable of reform their ships were Castles in transit 2 Revolutionary France, having cast out many of the old without providing a competent path for replacing with the new the spontaneity and shock on which Napoleon depended on land cou One of the best non fictions I have read This is seen by the fact I actually finished it and skimmed very little only the end in fact and that bc it was near bedtime Easy to read even without knowledge of ships ei my condition Big print is also a big plus NF with small print is too daunting for me